I have a problem with giants.jpg. It seems to me that it breaks an important
IRTC rule :

> 5. Image file
>
>	e. (...) You may not use an image that you created in the past. (...)

I had the feeling that I already saw this image somewhere. On some web
site I would not remember the name, perhaps? No! After checking, it
appears the very same image was submitted in 1998 november-december
round, under the name dpcgiants.jpg.

This, in fact, is not exactly the same image, when you come to look closely.
But the overall composition of the image is the very same. This is an improved
version, no a new one using previous work. And this is what the author says in
his accompanying text file.

So, I post this message in order to warn all who vote this round.
("Take what you think are appropriate measures")

This, by the way, raises a question : does anyone read the text
files? Okay, I know you do, so how does it come no one over a 10-day period
noticed the "This is a rework of an image I did two years ago" sentence?

Happy voting,


							Adrien

Post a reply to this message